Cooperage Inn
If you're ever in the mood for a relaxed and flavorful dining experience, Cooperage Inn is a must-visit. Located at 2218 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow, NY, this cozy spot is perfect for those looking to enjoy a meal with friends, family, or even colleagues. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or just out for a casual meal, Cooperage Inn provides the ideal setting.
The restaurant has a comfortable vibe, with moderate noise levels that make it a great place for groups to gather and enjoy conversation. Plus, with its outdoor seating options, you can take in the fresh air while indulging in some of their crowd-pleasing dishes. The atmosphere here is laid-back, making it perfect for kids, so you don’t have to worry about bringing your little ones along.
When it comes to food, Cooperage Inn offers a diverse menu that caters to a variety of tastes. One of their most popular dishes is the Chicken Pot Pie – a hearty and comforting classic that's always a hit. For seafood lovers, the Crab Cake Wrap and Crab Cakes are a must-try, packed with fresh, flavorful crab meat. And if you're in the mood for something a bit more adventurous, the Overstuffed Baked Clams are sure to satisfy your cravings.
The bread basket served at the start of your meal is another treat, offering a perfect accompaniment to any dish you choose. Whether you’re dining solo, on a date, or with a group, the food at Cooperage Inn won’t disappoint.
So, whether you're in the mood for comfort food or something with a little more flair, Cooperage Inn has you covered. It’s the kind of place where you can relax, enjoy good food, and make memories with those who matter most.
Reviews
An old favorite for sure! Traditional LI dinners. Great service for sure. On a chilly winter night a welcome sight for sure!
Right out of the gate... I big shout out to our wonderful Table Attendant, if you go to the Cooperage Inn ask for Angelina... Thank you Angelina for your kind and professional service! Ambiance... traditional, comfortable and delightfully "old timey"... warm woods, nice carpet, great fireplace... super duper... Food... the menu offers an interesting and glorious plethora of great options... you will be delighted with your choices... comfort food to the max... Okay, you ask...? Why 4 stars and not 5... I ordered the chicken pot pie... one of their specialties, I was excited and anxious to give it a try... UNFORTUNATELY THEIR WAS A PROBLEM WITH THE DISH... I immediately alerted "Angelina" and her response was immediate... concern, proactive and quickly provided a solution that resulted in a positive outcome in very short order... "... alls well that ends well..." When we dine out we have expectations... based on our PERSONAL experience I can state that when my wife and I dine at the Cooperage Inn again our confidence is very high and I know that we will have a positive experience... AND, SO WILL YOU! Go there... enjoy and please say hello to Angelina!
Came with family, party of 8 on Sunday before Christmas. The Cooperage has a warm & cozy cabin feel too it with rustic decor. It was packed, but i appreciated so much that there was ample space between tables. Even though it was crowded, it wasn't loud at all. We throughly enjoyed the space and time we were there, as we were not rushed at all. Loved that it was the regular menu, not abbreviated holiday menu as most restaurants do this time of year. Everything we enjoyed was outstanding. Everyone raved about their food, and we sampled plenty! Appetizers, dinners and desserts. The taste and the presentation were too notch. Our server was a nice gentleman. We are a high maintenance group (not me...others in our family party) and he delivered with a smile. Overall we had a great meal, a great time and some nice photos to remember our evening. I can't wait to go back.
After avoiding the Cooperage for 15 years I am happy to say we had a fabulous dinner! We had a reservation for 5 of us and we were seated immediately. We were not rushed at all despite the restaurant being quite busy. The holiday decor was inviting and the fireplace toasty Three of us enjoyed the Grouper special and boy was it ever delicious. Served over garlic mash potatoes and sautéd spinach. One person ordered the Francaise chicken and shrimp and another had the fabulous steak. Did I mention we all indulged in the bread basket and two orders of fried calamari Everything from start to finish was wonderful. Looks like we will be back again soon!!
Made a reservation for Valentine's Day dinner. Have always wanted to come here for many years! It was such a warm and cozy experience. They have a wide array of entrees and appetizers. Drinks were reasonably priced (not $20 like most places) We ordered the bread basket which comes with an assortment of breads. The zucchini bread was AMAZING! We decided on soups for appetizers; seafood bisque and french onion. Seafood bisque was rich with some clumps of crab. French onion was classic. We were already full after finishing this and still had bread left over. For my entree I choose the marinated grilled flat iron steak. Great portion size, steak was perfect. It had chimichurri sauce and gorgonzola cheese. Garlic mashed potatoes were fab. My partner ordered the stuffed shrimp. You can choose between 2 or 4 for a few more dollars. He loved it as well. No complaints at all. Service was great. Staff was lovely and attentive. Highly recommend a reservation as it is always busy! I've tried dining before without a reservation and it was over 2 hour wait over the summer.